It's been since 1960 when Ohio voted for the losing presidential candidate. Could it happen again in 2016?
Home / Battlegrounds / From Nixon To Trump: Could Ohio Get It Wrong?

From Nixon To Trump: Could Ohio Get It Wrong?

Sen. John F. Kennedy won the 1960 presidential election, defeating vice president Richard Nixon, but he did not carry the battleground state of Ohio. And it bothered him every time he thought about it.

As I wrote in my book Front Row Seat at the Circus:

The day after his first televised debate with Vice President Richard Nixon in 1960, Senator John F. Kennedy was campaigning in Canton, Ohio. During the fall he made stops in Cincinnati, Dayton, Toledo, Elyria, Youngstown, Lorain, and Cleveland where crowds often numbered over 20,000. Yet, on election night it was Nixon, not Kennedy, who carried the Buckeye State.

JFK is the last person to lose Ohio and still win the presidency, and he never really got over it. “There is no city in the United States where I get a warmer welcome and less votes than Columbus, Ohio,” JFK told an audience to laughter and applause in 1962.

That was a long time ago. Only about a third of America’s current population was alive when Kennedy moved into the White House. Thus why all modern presidential candidates have spent more time in Ohio than any other state.

It’s foolish to think you’re going to be president without it.

That was then, this is now.

Of the fifty states, Ohio has the longest streak of siding the winning presidential candidate. Not since 1960 has Ohio failed to be the political barometer of the nation.

But this year, after supporting Barack Obama in both 2008 and 2012, we are projecting a majority of Ohioans will side with Donald Trump.





An averaging of polls from the Buckeye State shows Trump beating Hillary Clinton by 3.5 percent. That’s a landslide in Ohio.

There are key reasons for Trump’s rise in this key battleground state:

  • Traditional working class Democratic voters in coal country — places like Youngstown — are backing Trump and not Clinton.
  • Millennials on college campuses across Ohio are not near as enthusiastic about Clinton as they were about Obama (and earlier this year Bernie Sanders). Some will skip voting altogether.
  • African American voters in Cuyahoga County could be down up to 35 percent from four years ago.
  • Suburban Republicans, who had been leaning toward Clinton prior to the FBI announcement about emails last week, are now backing the GOP nominee.

Obama only defeated Mitt Romney by 200,000 votes in Ohio four years ago. Split that in half, and Trump only needs to pick up 100,000 votes to turn that around. And we believe he has.

What this means is that Ohio, for the first time in most of our lifetimes, is going to get it wrong. Trump is going to win the Buckeye State, but lose the presidency.

As I also mentioned in my book, with the lack of a growing Hispanic population in the state, Ohio’s days as the ultimate political barometer in the land could be over.

About Jim Heath

Jim Heath is the author of the new best seller Front Row Seat at the Circus - One Journalist's Journey through Two Presidential Elections. The book is about Jim's experiences covering the 2008 and 2012 presidential campaigns - from South Carolina, the first southern primary state, to Ohio, the ultimate battleground state in presidential elections. A recipient of the Walter Cronkite Award for Excellence in Television Political Journalism, Jim is also a two-time Emmy award winner with more than 15 years experience as both a main evening anchor and political reporter. A longtime advocate of social media, GQ Magazine listed Jim on their Top 5 political "Power List" and the Washington Post named him to their "Best Super Tuesday Twitter List." Jim's news career has taken him from Arizona to South Carolina to Ohio.

Check Also

Trump Flips & Settles Trump U Case

Donald Trump once proclaimed “I don’t settle lawsuits!” but, like a lot of what we’ve …

Leave a Reply

Pin It on Pinterest

Share This